| 2025 | X Bill Hornbuckle | O Sue Laughlin | X O Gary Dawley |
| 2024 | X Charlotte Reigles | O Ron Bowerman | |
| 2023 | X O Alan Overbaugh | X Lee Coon | |
| 2022 | X Frank Kwiatkowski | | |
| 2021 | X Albert “Bucky” Buckland | | |
| 2020 | X O David “Eric” Conrad | | |
| 2019 | X Roger Chase | | |
| 2018 | O Ellen Perry | | |
| 2017 | No Inductees |
| 2016 | O Harold Uncapher | | |
| 2015 | No Inductees |
| 2014 | X Ernie Pound | | |
| 2013 | X Raymond Hall | X Lance Hinman | |
| 2012 | O Glen Addicott | | |
| 2011 | X Robert Klock | | |
| 2010 | X Albert Montroy | | |
| 2009 | O Marian Gee | X O Karen Graham | |
| 2008 | X Dave McCann | | |
| 2007 | X Victor Davis | X George Lovell | X Margaret Wilkinson |
| 2006 | X O John Merrill | O Stan Towne | |
| 2005 | X Leo Bukowski | | |
| 2004 | X Everett Warters | X Pete Newey | |
| 2003 | X Norm Wehrung | X Melvin “Luke” Luther | |
| 2002 | O Bob Hayes | X O Ken Fraser | |
| 2001 | X Glenn Brown | X Jack Stenberg | |
| 2000 | X Kenyon W.”Hoppy” Hopkins | X Harlan “Mac” McFann | |
| 1999 | X Dick Pike | X Lance Twyman | |
| 1998 | X Ernest Hilpertshauser | X Charles Reigles | |
| 1997 | X Richard Ellis | | |
| 1996 | O Sue Twyman | | |
| 1995 | X O James Sharkey | | |
| 1994 | X Helen Ouellette | O Tracy Warters Hastings | X Rod Pratt |
| 1993 | O John Bogardus | X Ken Nixon | |
| 1992 | No Inductees |
| 1991 | X Don Wilcox | O Lou Stines | |
| 1990 | X Kenyon V. “Ken” Hopkins | X John Loughery | |
| 1989 | O Bob Sutton | X Dean Rogers | |
| 1988 | O Chester Albertson | X Chuck Dickinson | |
| 1987 | O John Ruston | X Leo Ouellette | X William Walker |
| 1986 | X Ernie Graham | X Walt Hooley | |
| 1985 | O Mike DiMartino | X William Johnston | |
| 1984 | X Jack Townsend | O Ivan Tweedie | |
| 1983 | O Vivian Deuster | X August “Willie” Reich | |
| 1982 | X Donald Walker | O Arthur Tyson | |
| 1981 | O Walter Shackelton | O Edith Werth | |
| 1980 | O Lou Gancos | O George Hale | |
| 1979 | X Frank Disinger | O Joe Shultz | X Bill Fuller |
| 1978 | O Terrance “Red” Earley | X Paul Wilson | X Dominick P. Sharkey |
| 1977 | O Frank Michalek | X Paul Thomas | |
| 1976 | X Wilbert Hyland | X George LaRose | |
| 1975 | O Steve Fenicchia | O Anthony “Ginger” Natale | X Joe Pollock |
| 1975 | X Larry Proudman | O Anthony Sauro | O Joseph Zichella |
| 1974 | O Robert Brown | O Tom Brownell | X David D. Cottrell |
| 1974 | O Vito Fileccia | O Ruth Hangen | O Ruth Hoelzle |
| 1974 | X Bryon Jaskulek | O David T. Leonard | X Frank Niven |
| 1974 | O Carl Steinfeldt | O Lorraine Thomas | X Carl VonDerLancken |
